CBHL Logo CBHL Homepage

The Council on Botanical and Horticultural Libraries Annual Award
for a Significant Work in Botanical or Horticultural Literature

Contact -  Become a member -  Ask a plant librarian 

 Plant Libraries -  Publishers and Booksellers -  Resources -  Events  

About CBHL
Services &
    Activities
Annual Meetings
Annual Literature
    Award

Purpose
Winners
Current nominees
On this page Guidelines
On this page Judging criteria
Submit a title
Sponsor a title
Publishers' entry-form
For members only

CBHL Annual Literature Award
Guidelines, Judging Criteria & Submission Procedure

Guidelines of the Award

Nominations
Nominations must be submitted by a CBHL member. Publishers may submit works to be nominated by members. Works nominated the previous year may be nominated again if they meet the "Year of Publication" guideline below.
Author
The work may or may not be by a CBHL member. However, works by members of this Award Committee are not eligible. The work may be authored by one or more individuals, a group, or an organization.
Format
Acceptable formats include but are not limited to: book, journal, journal article, CD-ROM.
Language
Works should be in English or in English with parallel text in other languages.
Year of Publication/Creation
Works should be published or created in the two calendar years preceding the year the award will be presented. (For example, works published in 2004 and 2005 are eligible for the 2006 Award, which is given - in this case - at the 2006 Annual Meeting.)
Genre
Works are not limited by genre. Reference works, children's books, fiction, etc. are all acceptable.
Categories
The award committee may decide to attribute awards and mentions, in one or two categories.

CBHL Annual Literature Award Logo



Judging Criteria

Works will be judged by members of the Annual Literature Award Committee according to the following criteria:

Accuracy

Clarity

Organization and presentation of information

Usefulness to the intended audience

Uniqueness of the contribution to the literature of the field

Excellence of intellectual content

Design and composition of the work

Top of the pageTop of the page


Submission Procedure

Are you a CBHL member and would you like to nominate a work?

Complete the online nomination form or its printed version and send it to the Chair of the Annual Literature Award Committee. Nominations are to be taken for the subsequent year Award from mid-June to the Fall.


Sponsor a work submitted for review by publishers for the Annual Award. Nominate works from the list of titles submitted by publishers. Fill the online form when available.

Submit nomination information to any committee members. Use your Member Directory for contact information or email one of them:
Janet Evans, committee chair
, or
Céline Arseneault,
Patricia Jonas Brad Lyon
Brian Thompson
Gretchen Wade.

Do not hesitate to contact any committee member for comments, suggestions and more information.

Are you a publisher who wishes to suggest a work for the next award?

Contact Patricia Jonas or complete the submission form when available.

Top of the pageTop of the page

Annual Literature Award Page
Annual Literature Award Committee

   E-mail -  FAQ  -  Site Map  -  Credits  

HOME CBHL
CBHL
Updated 2006-08-23